My fail? I left the tables out year round and in Jersey, winter can do nasty things to art work. Did I not seal them good enough? Was it an especially harsh winter? Probably yes to all of the above. :(
So, I've been wanting to update it and didn't think the stain would work again so I dragged out my acrylic paint and a can of clear sealer and went to work.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/fbb0e/fbb0ec9ee5b51fec3d2aea66d18a5b989b9b4a72" alt=""
Next I filled in the peacock body in with a couple of shades of blue to give it some texture.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/31978/31978a5f1ff19e80d3d17e110760b5dc41ab46b7" alt=""
Next the eyes of the peacock feathers were painted with a blend of orange/yellow, a heart shaped blue, and purple dot. After that dried, long wavy lines were shadowed in to create that feathery look.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/aabce/aabcefe9e8c4473ab98217d6351b7f4c310f5073" alt=""
For the body lines of purple were placed just to give it a little feathery effect (without actually painting feathers.)
Three coats of sealer were sprayed over the top and sides to (hopefully) give it some protection from the elements.